“In the tenth century BC, the priests of India devised the Brahmodya competition, which would become a model of authentic theological discourse. The object was to find a verbal formula to define the Brahman, the ultimate and inexpressible reality beyond human understanding. The idea was to push language as far as it would go, until participants became aware of the ineffable. The challenger, drawing on his immense erudition, began the process by asking an enigmatic question and his opponents had to reply in a way that was apt but equally inscrutable. The winner was the contestant who reduced the others to silence. In that moment of silence, the Brahman was present – not in the ingenious verbal declarations but in the stunning realisation of the impotence of speech. Nearly all religious traditions have devised their own versions of this exercise. It was not a frustrating experience; the finale can, perhaps, be compared to the moment at the end of the symphony, when there is a full and pregnant beat of silence in the concert hall before the applause begins. The aim of good theology is to help the audience to live for a while in that silence.”
The Christian versions of this (I guess I’m thinking Saint Dionysius’s “Mystical Theology” and “The Divine Names” as a place to start) are not what we think about when we think about Christian theology, but apophasis is definitely there in the centre of the Patristics and mystical theology. May we all learn to allow for the silence which is the ground of meaning!
Louder Than Words
Maggie Ross gives some great ideas for taking on the discipline of Lent.